Pete’s Old Fashion Tomato Pies Menu

Introducing the Menu

At Pete’s Old Fashion Tomato Pies, pizza lovers are treated to an exceptional blend of simplicity and flavor, showcasing the best of Sicilian-style pies. Located at 2919 US-206, Columbus, NJ, Pete's delivers a nostalgic taste that has left many customers like Tom S. reminiscing about their childhood. The standout feature is the unique crust—crispy yet light, perfectly complementing the heavy tomato sauce and minimal cheese, providing a satisfying experience without overwhelming the palate.

Reviews highlight the inviting atmosphere and friendly service, making it a great spot for groups and families. Diners appreciate the fair pricing, with slices priced at just $2.50 and whole pies for $20, making it accessible for all. With the outdoor seating and ease of takeout or delivery, a visit to Pete’s Old Fashion Tomato Pies is a must for those seeking an authentic slice of Trenton-style pizza.